Versions Compared

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.


Tabs Container
directionhorizontal


Tabs Page
titleNederlands
Info
titleDefinition

Definitie van een microcredential
Een microcredential is een bewijs van de leerresultaten die een lerende heeft verworven na een korte leerervaring. Deze leerresultaten zijn beoordeeld aan de hand van transparante normen. Het bewijs is opgenomen in een gecertificeerd document dat de naam van de houder, de behaalde leerresultaten, de beoordelingsmethode, de uitreikende instelling en, indien van toepassing, het niveau van het kwalificatiekader en de behaalde studiepunten vermeldt. Micro-credentials zijn eigendom van de lerende, kunnen gedeeld worden, zijn overdraagbaar en kunnen gecombineerd worden tot grotere referenties of kwalificaties. Ze worden ondersteund door kwaliteitsborging volgens overeengekomen normen.

Referenties

Samenvatting

Om aan de EU definitie van een microcredential te kunnen voldoen zouden we de volgende aanpassingen kunnen maken aan edubadges en dit afstemmen met werkgroep metadata.

  • Ad 3: Verplicht veld - Country/region of the issuer → Toevoegen aan metadatamodel issuer: landcode: NL.
  • Ad 10: Verplicht veld - Form of participation in the learning activity →  Toevoegen aan metadatamodel badgeclass.
    Opties: Online, Onsite, Blended, Volunteering, Work experience, By choice of participant, Personalized learning activities / Online, Onsite, Blended, Vrijwilligerswerk, Werkervaring, Naar keuze deelnemer, Gepersonaliseerde leeractiviteiten
  • Ad 12: Verplicht veld - Type of assessment → Toevoegen aan metadatamodel badgeclass.
    Opties: Testing, Application of a skill, Portfolio, Recognition of prior learning, P
    ersonalized assessment, By choice of participant. / Toetsing, Toepassing van een vaardigheid, Portfolio, Erkenning van eerdere leerervaringen, Gepersonaliseerde toetsing, Naar keuze deelnemer. 
  • Ad 13: Optioneel veld - Supervision and identity verification during assessment → Toevoegen aan metadatamodel badgeclass.
    Opties: Unsupervised with no identity verification, Unsupervised with identity verification, Supervised with no identity verification, Supervised with identity verification. / Zonder toezicht zonder identiteitscontrole, Zonder toezicht met identiteitscontrole, Onder toezicht zonder identiteitscontrole, Onder toezicht met identiteitscontrole.
  • Ad 14: Optioneel veld - Quality assurance of the credential and, where relevant, of the learning content → Toevoegen aan metadatamodel badgeclass: Name, URL, Description
  • Ad 15: Optioneel veld - Grade achieved → Toevoegen aan metadatamodel assertion. Toevoegen als optie bij het uitreiken met de optie om dit een verplicht veld te maken zoals Narrative en Evidence. Grade: 8
  • Ad 16: Optioneel veld - Integration/stackability options → Toevoegen aan metadatamodel badgeclass.
    Opties in type badgeclasses: Standalone independent micro-credential, Stackable towards another credential / Zelfstandig onafhankelijk micro-credential, Stapelbaar ten opzichte van een ander credential.

Mapping Metadata Micro-credentials volgens EU op metadata Edubadges

Note: updated na analyse van "ANNEX I: European standard elements to describe a microcredential" in  Counsil recommendation may 22.pdf
Note: Groen gemarkeerde cellen geven aan dat de huidige edubadges metadata definitie al voldoet aan de EU definitie van een microcredential.

MANDATORYProposed EU Standard
EdubadgesJSON example
1Identification of the learner
Mandatory
Assertion: recipient

 "recipient": {
    "hashed": true,
    "type": "id",
    "identity": "sha256$e4e231ac272e2123ea643f509b0deed0bcf8c26010b253d0093cda7bdca77687",
    "salt": "70e57619251a4beeac4b75d1f5f834dc"
  }

2Title of the micro-credential
Mandatory
BadgeClass: name"name": "Economics Introduction Msc"
3Country(ies)/region(s) of the issuer
Mandatory

(nog) Niet in edubadges
Deze in de metadata van een instelling opnemen.

Issuer:
extensions:InstitutionCountryExtension

"extensions:InstitutionCountryExtension": {
    "@context": "https://api.edubadges.nl/extensions/InstitutionCountryExtension/context.json",
    "type": [
      "Extension",
      "extensions:InstitutionCountryExtension"
    ],
    "CountryCode": NL
  }

4Awarding body(ies)
Mandatory
BadgeClass: issuer

"issuer": "https://api.edubadges.nl/public/issuers/lQ67BQQQS-eBx5syJGpazg"

5Date of issuing
Mandatory
Assertion: issuedOn"issuedOn": "2020-08-31T14:41:09.930888+00:00"
6Learning outcomes
Mandatory
BadgeClass: extensions:LearningOutcomeExtension

"extensions:LearningOutcomeExtension": {
    "@context": "https://api.edubadges.nl/extensions/LearningOutcomeExtension/context.json",
    "type": [
      "Extension",
      "extensions:LearningOutcomeExtension"
    ],
    "LearningOutcome": "Develop the ability to explain core economic terms, concepts, and theories.\\n\\n1. Explain the function of market and prices as allocative mechanisms.\\n2. Apply the concept of equilibrium to both microeconomics and macroeconomics.\\n3. Identify key macroeconomic indicators and measures of economics change, growth, and development.\\n4. Identify and discuss the key concepts underlying comparative advantage.\\n5. Identify and explain major types of market failures.\\n"
  }

7Notional workload needed to achieve the learning outcomes
(in ECTS, wherever possible)
Mandatory
BadgeClass: extensions:ECTSExtension

"extensions:ECTSExtension": {
    "@context": "https://api.edubadges.nl/extensions/ECTSExtension/context.json",
    "type": [
      "Extension",
      "extensions:ECTSExtension"
    ],
    "ECTS": 10
  }

8Level (and cycle, if applicable) of the learning experience leading to the micro-credential(EQF, QF-EHEA and/or national qualifications framework) if appicable
Mandatory
BadgeClass: extensions:EQFExtension

"extensions:EQFExtension": {
    "@context": "https://api.edubadges.nl/extensions/EQFExtension/context.json",
    "type": [
      "Extension",
      "extensions:EQFExtension"
    ],
    "EQF": 6
  }

9Type of assessment
(testing, application of a skill,
portfolio, recognition of prior learning, etc.)
Mandatory

(nog) Niet in edubadges

→ Toevoegen aan metadatamodel badgeclass.
Opties: testing, application of a skill, portfolio, recognition of prior learning, 
personalized assessment, by choice of participant

 

BadgeClass: extensions:AssesmentTypeExtension

"extensions:AssesmentTypeExtension": {
    "@context": "https://api.edubadges.nl/extensions/AssesmentTypeExtension/context.json",
    "type": [
      "Extension",
      "extensions:AssesmentTypeExtension"
    ],
    "Type of assessment": "Testing, Application of a skill, Portfolio, Recognition of prior learning, personalized assessment, By choice of participant\\n"
  }


10Form of participation in the learning activity
(online, onsite or blended, volunteering, work experience)
Mandatory

(nog) Niet in edubadges

→  Toevoegen aan metadatamodel badgeclass. Opties: online, onsite, blended, volunteering, work experience, Personalized learning activities, By choice of participant

BadgeClass: extensions:ParticipationFormExtension

"extensions:ParticipationFormExtension": {
    "@context": "https://api.edubadges.nl/extensions/ParticipationFormExtension/context.json",
    "type": [
      "Extension",
      "extensions:ParticipationFormExtension"
    ],
    "Form of Participation": "Online, Onsite, Blended, Volunteering, Work experience, Personalized learning activities, By choice of participant\\n"
  }

11Type of quality assurance used to underpin the micro-credential
Mandatory

(nog) Niet in edubadges

Beter om hiervoor een apart Quality metadataveld voor te gebruiken en niet om het veld 'Related Educational Framework' te misbruiken hiervoor.
QualityAssuranceName, QualityAssuranceUrl, QualityAssuranceDescription

BadgeClass: extensions:QualityAssuranceExtension

"extensions:QualityAssuranceExtension": {
    "@context": "https://api.edubadges.nl/extensions/QualityAssuranceExtension/context.json",
    "type": [
      "Extension",
      "extensions:QualityAssuranceExtension"
    ],
   
"QualityAssuranceExtension"{
      "QualityAssuranceName": "Kwaliteitskader Microcredentials voor Professionals HBO en WO",
      "QualityAssuranceUrl": "https://www.versnellingsplan.nl/Kennisbank/pilot-microcredentials-2/",
      "QualityAssuranceDescription": "In het Nederlandse hoger onderwijs is in de afgelopen jaren een hoogwaardig stelsel van kwaliteitsborging gegroeid. Instellingen geven hier allen op hun eigen wijze kleur aan. Deze eigenheid en diversiteit kunnen beschouwd worden als een kracht van het stelsel, maar kan ook leiden tot discussie onderling wanneer gezocht wordt naar eenduidigheid. Daarom is gekozen voor een kwaliteitskader waarbinnen instellingen zoveel mogelijk (inhoudelijke) vrijheid genieten. De pilot geeft ruimte aan de instellingen om te starten met dit kader als vertrekpunt en deze al doende in gezamenlijkheid bij te schaven en verder in te vullen....."
    }
  }

OPTIONALProposed EU Standard
EdubadgesJSON example
12Prerequisites needed to enrol in the learning activity
Optional where relevant
BadgeClass: criteria

"criteria": {
    "id": "https://programstructure.example.org/",
    "narrative": "The holder of this Badge obtained the MSc in International Economics (120 ECTS) at the Example University. The Program Structure is available at this link. In order to obtain this degree, a student must enrol in and complete the corresponding study program at the Example University. When students complete the activities, ECTS (European Credit Transfer and Accumulation System) credits will be awarded. The ECTS is a credit system for higher education that allows comparison of study attainments of students across the European Union. In our University ECTS credits are awarded to students when they successfully complete learning activities, usually as follows: 1. regarding the taught courses, students must pass a final exam (written, oral, or both written and oral), achieving a mark equal to or better than 18/30; 2. regarding the professional training periods and practice, students must attend the majority of the course as compulsory (in general 70% of the total time) and must obtain a \\\"pass\\\" grade from the teacher (or from the tutor, or the supervisor); 3. regarding the workshops and fieldwork, students must: in certain cases, pass a final exam (written, oral, or both written and oral), achieving a mark equal to or better than 18/30, or, in other cases, attend the majority of the module/course as compulsory (in general 70% of the total time) and obtain a \\\"pass\\\" grade from the teacher (or from the tutor, or the supervisor); 4. students must prepare and discuss in open debate a dissertation on a chosen topic, based either on a research project or on a study of the relevant scientific literature. The final degree grade depends on: 1. the weighted grade point average of all grades obtained for all the learning activities, weighted by their ECTS credits; 2. quality of the final dissertation."
  }

13Supervision and identity verification during assessment
(unsupervised with no identity
verification, supervised with no identity verification, supervised online or onsite with identity verification)
Optional where relevant

Niet in edubadges (optioneel veld)

→ Toevoegen aan metadatamodel badgeclass. Opties: unsupervised with no identity verification, Unsupervised with identity verification, supervised with no identity verification, supervised with identity verification.

BadgeClass: extensions:SupervisionTypeExtension

"extensions:SupervisionTypeExtension": {
    "@context": "https://api.edubadges.nl/extensions/SupervisionTypeExtension/context.json",
    "type": [
      "Extension",
      "extensions:SupervisionTypeExtension"
    ],
    "Type of Supervision": "Unsupervised with no identity verification, Unsupervised with identity verification, Supervised with no identity verification, Supervised with identity verification.\\n"
  }


14Grade achieved
Optional where relevant

Niet in edubadges (optioneel veld)

→ Toevoegen als optie bij het uitreiken met de optie om dit een verplicht veld te maken zoals Narrative en Evidence. Eventueel zou je hier het narrative/evidence veld voor kunnen gebruiken.

BadgeClass: extensions:GradeAchievedExtension

"extensions:GradeAchievedExtension": {
    "@context": "https://api.edubadges.nl/extensions/GradeAchievedExtension/context.json",
    "type": [
      "Extension",
      "extensions:GradeAchievedExtension"
    ],
    "Grade Achieved": "8"
  }
15Integration/stackability options
(standalone, independent micro-credential / integrated, stackable towards another credential)
Optional where relevant

Niet in edubadges (optioneel veld)

→ Dit moet tot uiting komen wanneer we pathways supporten. Type badgeclasses: standalone, independent micro-credential / integrated, stackable towards another credential.

BadgeClass: extensions:IntegrationOptionsExtension

"extensions:IntegrationOptionsExtension": {
    "@context": "https://api.edubadges.nl/extensions/IntegrationOptionsExtension/context.json",
    "type": [
      "Extension",
      "extensions:IntegrationOptionsExtension"
    ],
    "IntegrationOptions": "Standalone, Independent microcredential / integrated, Stackable towards another credential.\\n"
  }
16Further information
Optional where relevant
BadgeClass: description"description": "This badge can be earned after completing the course Economics Introduction Msc study."

 

Welke metadata missen we dus nog?

Metadata extenties voor de Issuer

  • 1) InstitutionCountryExtension 
    Country(ies)/region(s) of the issuer → ISO 3166-2 (NL, DE, BE etc)
    EU: Mandatory

Metadata extenties voor de Badgeclass

  • 2) AssesmentTypeExtension
    Type of assessment → Options: Testing, Application of a skill, Portfolio, Recognition of prior learning, By choice of participant 
    EU: Mandatory

  • 3) ParticipationFormExtension
    Form of participation in the learning activity →  Options: Online, Onsite or blended, Volunteering, Work experience, Personalized learning activities
    EU: Mandatory

  • 4) QualityAssuranceExtension
    Type of quality assurance used to underpin the micro-credentialTitle, URL reference, Description.
    See also: https://github.com/edubadges/edubadges-ui/blob/develop/src/util/microcredentials.js
    EU: Mandatory

  • 5) SupervisionTypeExtension
    Supervision and identity verification during assessmentOptions: Unsupervised with no identity verification, Supervised with no identity verification, Supervised online or onsite with identity verification.
    EU: Optional

  • 6) IntegrationOptionsExtension
    Integration/stackability → Options: Standalone independent micro-credential, Stackable towards another credential
    EU: Optional

Metadata extenties voor de Assertion

  • 7) GradeAchievedExtension
    Grade achieved → In addition to the narrative and evidence data, the Grade achieved can be added when issuing the edubadge.
    EU: Optional


MANDATORYProposed EU Standard
EdubadgesJSON example

3

Status
colourGreen
titleIssuer

Country(ies)/region(s) of the issuer
Mandatory

(nog) Niet in edubadges
Deze in de metadata van een instelling opnemen.

Issuer:
extensions:InstitutionCountryExtension

"extensions:InstitutionCountryExtension": {
    "@context": "https://api.edubadges.nl/extensions/InstitutionCountryExtension/context.json",
    "type": [
      "Extension",
      "extensions:InstitutionCountryExtension"
    ],
    "CountryCode": NL
  }

9

Status
colourBlue
titleBadgeclass

Type of assessment
(testing, application of a skill,
portfolio, recognition of prior learning, etc.)
Mandatory

(nog) Niet in edubadges

→ Toevoegen aan metadatamodel badgeclass.
Opties: testing, application of a skill, portfolio, recognition of prior learning, 
personalized assessment, by choice of participant

 

BadgeClass: extensions:AssesmentTypeExtension

"extensions:AssesmentTypeExtension": {
    "@context": "https://api.edubadges.nl/extensions/AssesmentTypeExtension/context.json",
    "type": [
      "Extension",
      "extensions:AssesmentTypeExtension"
    ],
    "Type of assessment": "Testing, Application of a skill, Portfolio, Recognition of prior learning, personalized assessment, By choice of participant\\n"
  }


10

Status
colourBlue
titleBadgeclass

Form of participation in the learning activity
(online, onsite or blended, volunteering, work experience)
Mandatory

(nog) Niet in edubadges

→  Toevoegen aan metadatamodel badgeclass. Opties: online, onsite, blended, volunteering, work experience, Personalized learning activities, By choice of participant

BadgeClass: extensions:ParticipationFormExtension

"extensions:ParticipationFormExtension": {
    "@context": "https://api.edubadges.nl/extensions/ParticipationFormExtension/context.json",
    "type": [
      "Extension",
      "extensions:ParticipationFormExtension"
    ],
    "Form of Participation": "Online, Onsite, Blended, Volunteering, Work experience, Personalized learning activities, By choice of participant\\n"
  }

11

Status
colourBlue
titleBadgeclass

Type of quality assurance used to underpin the micro-credential
Mandatory

(nog) Niet in edubadges

Beter om hiervoor een apart Quality metadataveld voor te gebruiken en niet om het veld 'Related Educational Framework' te misbruiken hiervoor.
QualityAssuranceName, QualityAssuranceUrl, QualityAssuranceDescription

BadgeClass: extensions:QualityAssuranceExtension

"extensions:QualityAssuranceExtension": {
    "@context": "https://api.edubadges.nl/extensions/QualityAssuranceExtension/context.json",
    "type": [
      "Extension",
      "extensions:QualityAssuranceExtension"
    ],
   
"QualityAssuranceExtension"{
      "QualityAssuranceName": "Kwaliteitskader Microcredentials voor Professionals HBO en WO",
      "QualityAssuranceUrl": "https://www.versnellingsplan.nl/Kennisbank/pilot-microcredentials-2/",
      "QualityAssuranceDescription": "In het Nederlandse hoger onderwijs is in de afgelopen jaren een hoogwaardig stelsel van kwaliteitsborging gegroeid. Instellingen geven hier allen op hun eigen wijze kleur aan. Deze eigenheid en diversiteit kunnen beschouwd worden als een kracht van het stelsel, maar kan ook leiden tot discussie onderling wanneer gezocht wordt naar eenduidigheid. Daarom is gekozen voor een kwaliteitskader waarbinnen instellingen zoveel mogelijk (inhoudelijke) vrijheid genieten. De pilot geeft ruimte aan de instellingen om te starten met dit kader als vertrekpunt en deze al doende in gezamenlijkheid bij te schaven en verder in te vullen....."
    }
  }

13

Status
colourBlue
titleBadgeclass

Supervision and identity verification during assessment
(unsupervised with no identity
verification, supervised with no identity verification, supervised online or onsite with identity verification)
Optional where relevant

Niet in edubadges (optioneel veld)

→ Toevoegen aan metadatamodel badgeclass. Opties: unsupervised with no identity verification, Unsupervised with identity verification, supervised with no identity verification, supervised with identity verification.

BadgeClass: extensions:SupervisionTypeExtension

"extensions:SupervisionTypeExtension": {
    "@context": "https://api.edubadges.nl/extensions/SupervisionTypeExtension/context.json",
    "type": [
      "Extension",
      "extensions:SupervisionTypeExtension"
    ],
    "Type of Supervision": "Unsupervised with no identity verification, Unsupervised with identity verification, Supervised with no identity verification, Supervised with identity verification.\\n"
  }


14

Status
colourRed
titleAssertion

Grade achieved
Optional where relevant

Niet in edubadges (optioneel veld)

→ Toevoegen als optie bij het uitreiken met de optie om dit een verplicht veld te maken zoals Narrative en Evidence. Eventueel zou je hier het narrative/evidence veld voor kunnen gebruiken.

Assertion: 
extensions:GradeAchievedExtension

"extensions:GradeAchievedExtension": {
    "@context": "https://api.edubadges.nl/extensions/GradeAchievedExtension/context.json",
    "type": [
      "Extension",
      "extensions:GradeAchievedExtension"
    ],
    "Grade Achieved": "8"
  }

15

Status
colourBlue
titleBadgeclass

Integration/stackability options
(standalone, independent micro-credential / integrated, stackable towards another credential)
Optional where relevant

Niet in edubadges (optioneel veld)

→ Dit moet tot uiting komen wanneer we pathways supporten. Type badgeclasses: standalone, independent micro-credential / integrated, stackable towards another credential.

BadgeClass: extensions:IntegrationOptionsExtension

"extensions:IntegrationOptionsExtension": {
    "@context": "https://api.edubadges.nl/extensions/IntegrationOptionsExtension/context.json",
    "type": [
      "Extension",
      "extensions:IntegrationOptionsExtension"
    ],
    "IntegrationOptions": "Standalone, Independent microcredential / integrated, Stackable towards another credential.\\n"
  }


Note
titleFeedback van regiegroep Pilot Microcredentials

Ten eerste met betrekking tot de in de wiki opgenomen suggesties met betrekking tot mcs volgens de europese commissie t.a.v. de metadatavelden.
Vanuit de vertegenwoordigers van de koepels hierover de volgende feedback:

Ad 3 - de voorgestelde mogelijkheden lijken goed te passen.
Bij Ad 10 en Ad 12 de zouden wij graag de optie 'naar keuze deelnemer' (by choice of participant) toevoegen op basis van ervaringen in de instellingen. 
Participatie in leeractiviteiten is namelijk niet altijd verplicht en/of eenduidig. Trajecten kunnen ook bewust leerwegonafhankelijk worden aanboden. Dit geldt ook voor toetsing. Er bestaat aanbod waarbij de deelnemer zelf mag voorstellen hoe hij of zij de leeruitkomsten aantoont. 

Zie ook: https://open.overheid.nl/repository/ronl-44276b30-c94b-4901-8497-868b9c394c4d/1/pdf/position-paper-by-the-netherlands-microcredentials-euconsultation.pdf

Advies regiegroep pilot microcredentials m.b.t. metadatavelden dienst edubadges 

Het advies van de regiegroep met betrekking tot de inrichting van de metadatavelden van de dienst op basis van input van de instellingen is de genoemde velden optioneel toe te voegen.  
Bij de Velden ‘Form of participation in learning activity’​ en ‘Form of assessement’ adviseert de regiegroep de volgende antwoordmogelijkheid toe te voegen, om aan te sluiten bij de Nederlandse onderwijscontext: 

  • Form of participation in learning activity​ - Gepersonaliseerde leeractiviteiten / Personalized learning activities
  • Form of assessment –  Gepersonaliseerde toetsing / personalized assessment 


Tabs Page
titleEnglish
Info
titleDefinition

Definition of a Microcredential
A microcredential is a proof of the learning out
comes that a learner has acquired following a short learning experience. These learning outcomes have been assessed against transparent standards.The proof is contained in a certified document that lists the name of the holder, the achieved learning outcomes, the assessment method, the awarding body and, where applicable, the qualifications framework level and the credits gained. Micro-credentials are owned by the learner, can be shared, are portable and may be combined into larger credentials or qualifications. They are under-pinned by quality assurance following agreed standards.

References

Summary

To meet the EU definition of a microcredential, we could make the following adjustments to edubadges and align this with working group metadata.

  • Ad 3: Mandatory field - Country/region of the issuer → Add to metadata model issuer: landcode: NL.
  • Ad 10: Mandatory field - Form of participation in the learning activity →  Add to metadata model badgeclass.
    Options: Online, Onsite, Blended, Volunteering, Work experience, By choice of participant, Personalized learning activities / Online, Onsite, Blended, Vrijwilligerswerk, Werkervaring, Naar keuze deelnemer, Gepersonaliseerde leeractiviteiten
  • Ad 12: Mandatory field - Type of assessment → Add to metadata model badgeclass.
    Options: Testing, Application of a skill, Portfolio, Recognition of prior learning, P
    ersonalized assessment, By choice of participant. / Toetsing, Toepassing van een vaardigheid, Portfolio, Erkenning van eerdere leerervaringen, Gepersonaliseerde toetsing, Naar keuze deelnemer. 
  • Ad 13: Optional field - Supervision and identity verification during assessment → Add to metadata model badgeclass.
    Options: Unsupervised with no identity verification, Unsupervised with identity verification, Supervised with no identity verification, Supervised with identity verification. / Zonder toezicht zonder identiteitscontrole, Zonder toezicht met identiteitscontrole, Onder toezicht zonder identiteitscontrole, Onder toezicht met identiteitscontrole.
  • Ad 14: Optional field - Quality assurance of the credential and, where relevant, of the learning content → Add to metadata model badgeclass: Name, URL, Description
  • Ad 15: Optional field - Grade achieved → Add to metadata model assertion. Toevoegen als optie bij het uitreiken met de optie om dit een verplicht veld te maken zoals Narrative en Evidence. Grade: 8
  • Ad 16: Optional field - Integration/stackability options → Add to metadata model badgeclass.
    Options in type badgeclasses: Standalone independent micro-credential, Stackable towards another credential / Zelfstandig onafhankelijk micro-credential, Stapelbaar ten opzichte van een ander credential.

Mapping Metadata Microcredentials according to EU on metadata Edubadges

Note: updated after analysis of "ANNEX I: European standard elements to describe a micro-credential" in  Counsil recommendation may 22.pdf
Note: Green highlighted cells indicate that the current edubadges metadata definition meets the EU definition of a microcredential.

MANDATORYProposed EU Standard
EdubadgesJSON example
1Identification of the learner
Mandatory
Assertion: recipient

 "recipient": {
    "hashed": true,
    "type": "id",
    "identity": "sha256$e4e231ac272e2123ea643f509b0deed0bcf8c26010b253d0093cda7bdca77687",
    "salt": "70e57619251a4beeac4b75d1f5f834dc"
  }

2Title of the micro-credential
Mandatory
BadgeClass: name"name": "Economics Introduction Msc"
3Country(ies)/region(s) of the issuer
Mandatory

Not (yet) in edubadges

Include it in an institution's metadata.

Issuer:
extensions:InstitutionCountryExtension

"extensions:InstitutionCountryExtension": {
    "@context": "https://api.edubadges.nl/extensions/InstitutionCountryExtension/context.json",
    "type": [
      "Extension",
      "extensions:InstitutionCountryExtension"
    ],
    "CountryCode": NL
  }

4Awarding body(ies)
Mandatory
BadgeClass: issuer

"issuer": "https://api.edubadges.nl/public/issuers/lQ67BQQQS-eBx5syJGpazg"

5Date of issuing
Mandatory
Assertion: issuedOn"issuedOn": "2020-08-31T14:41:09.930888+00:00"
6Learning outcomes
Mandatory
BadgeClass: extensions:LearningOutcomeExtension

"extensions:LearningOutcomeExtension": {
    "@context": "https://api.edubadges.nl/extensions/LearningOutcomeExtension/context.json",
    "type": [
      "Extension",
      "extensions:LearningOutcomeExtension"
    ],
    "LearningOutcome": "Develop the ability to explain core economic terms, concepts, and theories.\\n\\n1. Explain the function of market and prices as allocative mechanisms.\\n2. Apply the concept of equilibrium to both microeconomics and macroeconomics.\\n3. Identify key macroeconomic indicators and measures of economics change, growth, and development.\\n4. Identify and discuss the key concepts underlying comparative advantage.\\n5. Identify and explain major types of market failures.\\n"
  }

7Notional workload needed to achieve the learning outcomes
(in ECTS, wherever possible)
Mandatory
BadgeClass: extensions:ECTSExtension

"extensions:ECTSExtension": {
    "@context": "https://api.edubadges.nl/extensions/ECTSExtension/context.json",
    "type": [
      "Extension",
      "extensions:ECTSExtension"
    ],
    "ECTS": 10
  }

8Level (and cycle, if applicable) of the learning experience leading to the micro-credential(EQF, QF-EHEA and/or national qualifications framework) if appicable
Mandatory
BadgeClass: extensions:EQFExtension

"extensions:EQFExtension": {
    "@context": "https://api.edubadges.nl/extensions/EQFExtension/context.json",
    "type": [
      "Extension",
      "extensions:EQFExtension"
    ],
    "EQF": 6
  }

9Type of assessment
(testing, application of a skill,
portfolio, recognition of prior learning, etc.)
Mandatory

Not (yet) in edubadges

→ Add to metadata model badgeclass.
Options: testing, application of a skill, portfolio, recognition of prior learning, personalized assessment, by choice of participant

 

BadgeClass: extensions:AssesmentTypeExtension

"extensions:AssesmentTypeExtension": {
    "@context": "https://api.edubadges.nl/extensions/AssesmentTypeExtension/context.json",
    "type": [
      "Extension",
      "extensions:AssesmentTypeExtension"
    ],
    "Type of assessment": "Testing, Application of a skill, Portfolio, Recognition of prior learning, personalized assessment, By choice of participant\\n"
  }


10Form of participation in the learning activity
(online, onsite or blended, volunteering, work experience)
Mandatory

Not (yet) in edubadges

→  Add to metadata model badgeclass.
Options: online, onsite, blended, volunteering, work experience, Personalized learning activities,
By choice of participant

BadgeClass: extensions:ParticipationFormExtension

"extensions:ParticipationFormExtension": {
    "@context": "https://api.edubadges.nl/extensions/ParticipationFormExtension/context.json",
    "type": [
      "Extension",
      "extensions:ParticipationFormExtension"
    ],
    "Form of Participation": "Online, Onsite, Blended, Volunteering, Work experience, Personalized learning activities, By choice of participant\\n"
  }

11Type of quality assurance used to underpin the micro-credential
Mandatory

Not (yet) in edubadges

Better to use a separate Quality metadata field for this and not misuse the 'Related Educational Framework' field for this.
QualityAssuranceName, QualityAssuranceUrl, QualityAssuranceDescription

BadgeClass: extensions:QualityAssuranceExtension

"extensions:QualityAssuranceExtension": {
    "@context": "https://api.edubadges.nl/extensions/QualityAssuranceExtension/context.json",
    "type": [
      "Extension",
      "extensions:QualityAssuranceExtension"
    ],
   
"QualityAssuranceExtension"{
      "QualityAssuranceName": "Kwaliteitskader Microcredentials voor Professionals HBO en WO",
      "QualityAssuranceUrl": "https://www.versnellingsplan.nl/Kennisbank/pilot-microcredentials-2/",
      "QualityAssuranceDescription": "In het Nederlandse hoger onderwijs is in de afgelopen jaren een hoogwaardig stelsel van kwaliteitsborging gegroeid. Instellingen geven hier allen op hun eigen wijze kleur aan. Deze eigenheid en diversiteit kunnen beschouwd worden als een kracht van het stelsel, maar kan ook leiden tot discussie onderling wanneer gezocht wordt naar eenduidigheid. Daarom is gekozen voor een kwaliteitskader waarbinnen instellingen zoveel mogelijk (inhoudelijke) vrijheid genieten. De pilot geeft ruimte aan de instellingen om te starten met dit kader als vertrekpunt en deze al doende in gezamenlijkheid bij te schaven en verder in te vullen....."
    }
  }

OPTIONALProposed EU Standard
EdubadgesJSON example
12Prerequisites needed to enrol in the learning activity
Optional where relevant
BadgeClass: criteria

"criteria": {
    "id": "https://programstructure.example.org/",
    "narrative": "The holder of this Badge obtained the MSc in International Economics (120 ECTS) at the Example University. The Program Structure is available at this link. In order to obtain this degree, a student must enrol in and complete the corresponding study program at the Example University. When students complete the activities, ECTS (European Credit Transfer and Accumulation System) credits will be awarded. The ECTS is a credit system for higher education that allows comparison of study attainments of students across the European Union. In our University ECTS credits are awarded to students when they successfully complete learning activities, usually as follows: 1. regarding the taught courses, students must pass a final exam (written, oral, or both written and oral), achieving a mark equal to or better than 18/30; 2. regarding the professional training periods and practice, students must attend the majority of the course as compulsory (in general 70% of the total time) and must obtain a \\\"pass\\\" grade from the teacher (or from the tutor, or the supervisor); 3. regarding the workshops and fieldwork, students must: in certain cases, pass a final exam (written, oral, or both written and oral), achieving a mark equal to or better than 18/30, or, in other cases, attend the majority of the module/course as compulsory (in general 70% of the total time) and obtain a \\\"pass\\\" grade from the teacher (or from the tutor, or the supervisor); 4. students must prepare and discuss in open debate a dissertation on a chosen topic, based either on a research project or on a study of the relevant scientific literature. The final degree grade depends on: 1. the weighted grade point average of all grades obtained for all the learning activities, weighted by their ECTS credits; 2. quality of the final dissertation."
  }

13Supervision and identity verification during assessment
(unsupervised with no identity
verification, supervised with no identity verification, supervised online or onsite with identity verification)
Optional where relevant

Not (yet) in edubadges (optional)

→ Add to metadata model badgeclass. Opties: Unsupervised with no identity verification, Unsupervised with identity verification, Supervised with no identity verification, Supervised with identity verification.

BadgeClass: extensions:SupervisionTypeExtension

"extensions:SupervisionTypeExtension": {
    "@context": "https://api.edubadges.nl/extensions/SupervisionTypeExtension/context.json",
    "type": [
      "Extension",
      "extensions:SupervisionTypeExtension"
    ],
    "Type of Supervision": "Unsupervised with no identity verification, Unsupervised with identity verification, Supervised with no identity verification, Supervised with identity verification.\\n"
  }


14Grade achieved
Optional where relevant

Not (yet) in edubadges (optional)

→ Add as an option when issuing with the option to make this a mandatory field like Narrative and Evidence. Optionally, you could use the narrative/evidence field for this.

BadgeClass: extensions:GradeAchievedExtension

"extensions:GradeAchievedExtension": {
    "@context": "https://api.edubadges.nl/extensions/GradeAchievedExtension/context.json",
    "type": [
      "Extension",
      "extensions:GradeAchievedExtension"
    ],
    "Grade Achieved": "8"
  }
15Integration/stackability options
(standalone, independent micro-credential / integrated, stackable towards another credential)
Optional where relevant

Not (yet) in edubadges (optional)

→  This should be reflected when we support pathways. Type badgeclasses: standalone, independent micro-credential / integrated, stackable towards another credential.

BadgeClass: extensions:IntegrationOptionsExtension

"extensions:IntegrationOptionsExtension": {
    "@context": "https://api.edubadges.nl/extensions/IntegrationOptionsExtension/context.json",
    "type": [
      "Extension",
      "extensions:IntegrationOptionsExtension"
    ],
    "IntegrationOptions": "Standalone, Independent microcredential / integrated, Stackable towards another credential.\\n"
  }
16Further information
Optional where relevant
BadgeClass: description"description": "This badge can be earned after completing the course Economics Introduction Msc study."

So what metadata are we still missing?

Metadata extensions for the Issuer

  • 1) InstitutionCountryExtension 
    Country(ies)/region(s) of the issuer → ISO 3166-2 (NL, DE, BE etc)
    EU: Mandatory

Metadata extensions for the Badgeclass

  • 2) AssesmentTypeExtension
    Type of assessment → Options: Testing, Application of a skill, Portfolio, Recognition of prior learning, By choice of participant 
    EU: Mandatory

  • 3) ParticipationFormExtension
    Form of participation in the learning activity →  Options: Online, Onsite or blended, Volunteering, Work experience, Personalized learning activities
    EU: Mandatory

  • 4) QualityAssuranceExtension
    Type of quality assurance used to underpin the micro-credentialTitle, URL reference, Description.
    See also: https://github.com/edubadges/edubadges-ui/blob/develop/src/util/microcredentials.js
    EU: Mandatory

  • 5) SupervisionTypeExtension
    Supervision and identity verification during assessmentOptions: Unsupervised with no identity verification, Supervised with no identity verification, Supervised online or onsite with identity verification.
    EU: Optional

  • 6) IntegrationOptionsExtension
    Integration/stackability → Options: Standalone independent micro-credential, Stackable towards another credential
    EU: Optional

Metadata extensions for the  Assertion

  • 7) GradeAchievedExtension
    Grade achieved → In addition to the narrative and evidence data, the Grade achieved can be added when issuing the edubadge.
    EU: Optional

 

MANDATORYProposed EU Standard
EdubadgesJSON example

3

Status
colourGreen
titleIssuer

Country(ies)/region(s) of the issuer
Mandatory

Not (yet) in edubadges
Include these in an institution's metadata.

Issuer:
extensions:InstitutionCountryExtension

"extensions:InstitutionCountryExtension": {
    "@context": "https://api.edubadges.nl/extensions/InstitutionCountryExtension/context.json",
    "type": [
      "Extension",
      "extensions:InstitutionCountryExtension"
    ],
    "CountryCode": NL
  }

9

Status
colourBlue
titleBadgeclass

Type of assessment
(testing, application of a skill,
portfolio, recognition of prior learning, etc.)
Mandatory

Not (yet) in edubadges

→ Add to metadata model badgeclass.

Options: testing, application of a skill, portfolio, recognition of prior learning, personalized assessment, by choice of participant

 BadgeClass: extensions:AssesmentTypeExtension

"extensions:AssesmentTypeExtension": {
    "@context": "https://api.edubadges.nl/extensions/AssesmentTypeExtension/context.json",
    "type": [
      "Extension",
      "extensions:AssesmentTypeExtension"
    ],
    "Type of assessment": "Testing, Application of a skill, Portfolio, Recognition of prior learning, personalized assessment, By choice of participant\\n"
  }


10

Status
colourBlue
titleBadgeclass

Form of participation in the learning activity
(online, onsite or blended, volunteering, work experience)
Mandatory

Not (yet) in edubadges

→  Add to metadata model badgeclass.

Options: online, onsite, blended, volunteering, work experience, Personalized learning activities, By choice of participant

BadgeClass: extensions:ParticipationFormExtension

"extensions:ParticipationFormExtension": {
    "@context": "https://api.edubadges.nl/extensions/ParticipationFormExtension/context.json",
    "type": [
      "Extension",
      "extensions:ParticipationFormExtension"
    ],
    "Form of Participation": "Online, Onsite, Blended, Volunteering, Work experience, Personalized learning activities, By choice of participant\\n"
  }

11

Status
colourBlue
titleBadgeclass

Type of quality assurance used to underpin the micro-credential
Mandatory

Not (yet) in edubadges

Better to use a separate Quality metadata field for this and not misuse the 'Related Educational Framework' field for this.

QualityAssuranceName, QualityAssuranceUrl, QualityAssuranceDescription

BadgeClass: extensions:QualityAssuranceExtension

"extensions:QualityAssuranceExtension": {
    "@context": "https://api.edubadges.nl/extensions/QualityAssuranceExtension/context.json",
    "type": [
      "Extension",
      "extensions:QualityAssuranceExtension"
    ],
   
"QualityAssuranceExtension"{
      "QualityAssuranceName": "Kwaliteitskader Microcredentials voor Professionals HBO en WO",
      "QualityAssuranceUrl": "https://www.versnellingsplan.nl/Kennisbank/pilot-microcredentials-2/",
      "QualityAssuranceDescription": "In het Nederlandse hoger onderwijs is in de afgelopen jaren een hoogwaardig stelsel van kwaliteitsborging gegroeid. Instellingen geven hier allen op hun eigen wijze kleur aan. Deze eigenheid en diversiteit kunnen beschouwd worden als een kracht van het stelsel, maar kan ook leiden tot discussie onderling wanneer gezocht wordt naar eenduidigheid. Daarom is gekozen voor een kwaliteitskader waarbinnen instellingen zoveel mogelijk (inhoudelijke) vrijheid genieten. De pilot geeft ruimte aan de instellingen om te starten met dit kader als vertrekpunt en deze al doende in gezamenlijkheid bij te schaven en verder in te vullen....."
    }
  }

13

Status
colourBlue
titleBadgeclass

Supervision and identity verification during assessment
(unsupervised with no identity
verification, supervised with no identity verification, supervised online or onsite with identity verification)
Optional where relevant

Not in edubadges (optional field)

→ Add to metadata model badgeclass.

Options: unsupervised with no identity verification, Unsupervised with identity verification, supervised with no identity verification, supervised with identity verification.

BadgeClass: extensions:SupervisionTypeExtension

"extensions:SupervisionTypeExtension": {
    "@context": "https://api.edubadges.nl/extensions/SupervisionTypeExtension/context.json",
    "type": [
      "Extension",
      "extensions:SupervisionTypeExtension"
    ],
    "Type of Supervision": "Unsupervised with no identity verification, Unsupervised with identity verification, Supervised with no identity verification, Supervised with identity verification.\\n"
  }


14

Status
colourRed
titleAssertion

Grade achieved
Optional where relevant

Not in edubadges (optional field)

→ Add as an option when issuing with the option to make this a mandatory field like Narrative and Evidence. Optionally, you could use the narrative/evidence field for this.

Assertion: 
extensions:GradeAchievedExtension

"extensions:GradeAchievedExtension": {
    "@context": "https://api.edubadges.nl/extensions/GradeAchievedExtension/context.json",
    "type": [
      "Extension",
      "extensions:GradeAchievedExtension"
    ],
    "Grade Achieved": "8"
  }

15

Status
colourBlue
titleBadgeclass

Integration/stackability options
(standalone, independent micro-credential / integrated, stackable towards another credential)
Optional where relevant

Not in edubadges (optional field)

→ This should be reflected when we support pathways. Type badgeclasses: standalone, independent micro-credential / integrated, stackable towards another credential.

BadgeClass: extensions:IntegrationOptionsExtension

"extensions:IntegrationOptionsExtension": {
    "@context": "https://api.edubadges.nl/extensions/IntegrationOptionsExtension/context.json",
    "type": [
      "Extension",
      "extensions:IntegrationOptionsExtension"
    ],
    "IntegrationOptions": "Standalone, Independent microcredential / integrated, Stackable towards another credential.\\n"
  }



Note
titleFeedback van regiegroep Pilot Microcredentials

Firstly, regarding the suggestions included in the wiki regarding mcs according to the european commission regarding metadata fields.
From the umbrella representatives on this, the following feedback:

Re 3 - the proposed options seem a good fit.

In Ad 10 and Ad 12 the we would like to add the option 'by choice of participant' based on experiences in the institutions. 
After all, participation in learning activities is not always compulsory and/or unambiguous. Pathways can also be offered deliberately independent of learning pathways. This also applies to assessment. There are offers where the participant may propose how he or she demonstrates learning outcomes. 

See also: https://open.overheid.nl/repository/ronl-44276b30-c94b-4901-8497-868b9c394c4d/1/pdf/position-paper-by-the-netherlands-microcredentials-euconsultation.pdf

Advice of the direction group pilot microcredentials with regard to the metadata fields of the edubadges service 

Based on input from the institutions, the direction group's recommendation regarding the design of the service's metadata fields is to optionally add the aforementioned fields.  
For the Fields 'Form of participation in learning activity' and 'Form of assessment', the direction group recommends adding the following response option, to fit the Dutch educational context: 

  • Form of participation in learning activity​ - Gepersonaliseerde leeractiviteiten / Personalized learning activities
  • Form of assessment –  Gepersonaliseerde toetsing / personalized assessment